Posts Tagged Cuyahoga County
Game Being Played by Larry Dolan and Gateway
Posted by Roldo Bartimole in Economic Development, Media, People, Politicians on May 20, 2010
May 20, 2010… It was a pleasure to see The Plain Dealer’s front page today. The PD for the first time in my memory asked a question that needed to be asked: “If Progressive Field needs improvements, who will pay the bill?” It was played prominently on Page One.
If there is any other board that needs PD probing besides the Port Authority it is the Gateway Economic Development Corp., the entity Cuyahoga County set up to own and operate the baseball field and the basketball arena (Progressive Field and the Quicken Arena).
It too has operated in vacuum, unwatched and unattended.
The answers to question about the so-called improvement at the baseball field are evasive both from the Cleveland Indians and from Gateway. True to standard.
Here’s what Indians PR spokesperson Bob DiBiasio said about the big but undisclosed plans, “We’re not there yet. It’s not a question that needs to be asked yet.”
Doesn’t need to be answered? That is strict PR bullshit from someone who never gets challenged by the news media. A happy face he has but not a trustful one for me. If you believe him on this one I have some special mortgage bonds to sell you.
“The Indians have not made any requests for alterations or payments,” was the answer from Gateway’s top operating official Todd Greathouse. Equally evasive. But not unexpected.
Don’t you think that the owner – Gateway – might want to inquire and have that information, especially when it has been in Crain’s Cleveland Business, online in my posts and now in the PD? And it could cost you millions of dollars? Oh why get testy.
It’s the disgusting proof – long tradition – that the owner are not in control of their facilities. The tenants are.
The question is WHO WILL PAY – THE TEAM OR THE PUBLIC?
Let me tell you. You will pay.
The PD – and I hope this ends the marriage the paper has had with Gateway – has been wed to Gateway and its desires from the beginning.
But the writing was on the wall.
Here’s what I wrote in the City News in April 2005:
“Gateway Economic Development Corp. Chairman Bill Reidy let it drop quietly, almost nonchalantly, during a non-eventful quarterly meeting a week ago.
“Reidy said that ‘the city and county would have to step in’ and put up money for Gateway’s capital fund when major repairs are necessary at Jacobs Field and Gund Arena (the original names for the two facilities
“What?” I wrote. Did I hear that right?
“Haven’t taxpayers paid enough for Gateway? Now Reidy wants the taxpayers to dig into their pockets for possibly hundreds of thousands of dollar in capital expenses that Gateway should have been putting aside itself,” I continued.
“Gateway, however, can’t put money aside because it has never charged the teams enough to maintain Jacobs Field and Gund Arena,” I went on.
“What’s so upsetting about this is that at that same meeting new representatives from the city – Chris Ronayne, Mayor Jane Campbell’s chief of staff – and Dennis Madden –Cuyahoga County Administrator – said nothing about this raid on their respective treasuries.” Somebody wake up our officials.
Let me tell you what I expect is happening.
Larry Dolan – and I expect Dan Gilbert won’t be far behind – has set in motion “improvements” at Progressive that will cost in the millions of dollars.
It will take some time.
But there will be money around. The sin tax extension of 10 years has a stipulation that the revenue up to $116 million will go to help pay for Browns Stadium for the City of Cleveland. However, once that total is reached the money – some $68 million had been the estimate – will go to the County. The tax has raised $94.3 million. So it’s not far from the $116 and is coming in at some $13 million a year.
The new money is not to go to Gateway. It is supposed to go to the County general fund. Where it is needed, I might add.
Watch County officials for the rest of this year. They must not be allowed to make any revisions that would send this money to Gateway.
At the time of the Reidy statement, I quoted a County official and wrote:
“’This is our money,’ said a County official. He went on to say, the County has paid an extra $100 million on other bonds and has to continue to paying. Now, it should derive the benefit from the 10 extra years of the sin tax, he said.”
So that’s the game – using more public dollars to boost the revenue of the teams.
My other suspicion, Dolan will use the improvement to help the revenue for the team and make it more valuable for sale purposes. Forbes in assessing the value of MLB teams puts the Indians at $391 million team value. Dolan bought the team for $323 from Dick Jacobs.
Do you think we ought to put a Dolan in as the County Chief executive to help rule whether the Cleveland Indians should get a helping of that $68 million coming due.” Matt Dolan has moved into Cuyahoga County to run for chief executive. Who would he represent in such a deal – his family or county taxpayers?
I think I know the answer.
My question is whether the Plain Dealer will deal with this money grab honestly. I hope so. But the PD’s record on this score is about as good as guys named Hagan, Dimora and Russo.
Here is the PD story:
Here was my take on the improvement deal: click here.
Do Taxpayers of Cleveland & Cuyahoga Have to Always Carry the Cost of Institutions that Serve a Much Wider Area of Northeast Ohio?
Posted by Roldo Bartimole in Economic Development, Politicians on May 6, 2010
May 6, 2010… I read in the New York Times Friday that plans are being formulated to redo Progressive Field. Who knew?
A Gateway official says, however, that there is no big redo coming. Further, at this point, both teams leasing sports facilities are responsible for capital improvements.
But don’t you know that it is coming: We need a new stadium! The Indians might leave town! What we’ve heard before we will hear again. It’s only a matter of time.
It does bring up the question of how Cleveland and Cuyahoga County can continue to afford to build and support major institutions that serve a larger geographic area. Not only sports but cultural.
It does seem past the time for thinking about how we preserve the many facilities, institutions and infrastructure assets of Cleveland. The city is rich in major sports and cultural institutions, relics of a wealthier era. How can they be preserved? Who will pay for them?
Most of the actual institutions servicing Northeastern Ohio residents physically are in Cleveland or Cuyahoga County. Does that mean only those residents enjoy those venues? Of course not.
Progressive Field, Quicken Arena, Browns Stadium, Playhouse Square’s stages (Allen, Ohio, State, Palace theaters), the Cleveland Art Museum, Severance Hall and the Cleveland Orchestra. Even the highly subsidized downtown assets of Cleveland. These are places that serve a wider area of northeast Ohio, not just Cleveland or Cuyahoga residents.
But the bill to pay for these important institutions seems to fall, at least the public portion, most heavily upon Cleveland and Cuyahoga taxpayers. Every day in almost every way. And, unfortunately, they are regressive sales taxes weighing heavily on lower and middle income people. None are progressive taxes. Thanks to people like Tim Hagan and Mike White, George Voinovich and George Forbes.
In the latest County Auditor reports we get an idea of the tax burden here:
- The Medical Mart/Convention Center – Cuyahoga taxpayers have contributed via the quarter percent sale tax hike – $94,379,438.38 since only January 2008. Cuyahoga residents will be paying this tax for 20 years.
- Browns Stadium – Cuyahoga taxpayers have contributed via various alcohol sales taxes – $64,609,806.86 since August 2005. The tax previously amounted to some $266 million to help pay for some of Gateway’s costs at the baseball and basketball facilities. The tax was levied for 15 years for Gateway and 10 more years for the football stadium, taking us to 2015. Hopefully, not to be renewed.
- The Arts & Culture tax – Cuyahoga taxpayers have been paying this tax on cigarettes – $60,724,894.40 – Cuyahoga has been paying this tax since February 2007. It’s a tax that I believe will be extended on and on.
That adds up to some $220 million in taxes (not counting the $266 million for Gateway) on Cuyahoga taxpayers with tens of millions more to be collected before these taxes run out.
These taxes will continue for many years.
Cleveland and Cuyahoga County are both losing population. That means there are fewer people paying these taxes.
We see the effect it has had on RTA. The transit system depends also on the shrinking sales tax, one percent of the 7.75 sales tax, highest of any county in Ohio. Fewer people mean less purchasing thus less sales tax revenue. Population losses and higher percentages of poor people suggest further erosion of sales tax revenue.
The burden of these seemingly small taxes is heavy. They go from taxes on almost all alcoholic drinks, cigarettes, to parking and other revenue, such as the city’s parking revenue.
The latest tax increase county taxpayers are enduring is the added sales tax of one-quarter percent that raises some $40 million a year for a convention center and medical mart. These facilities serve far more than the people of Cleveland or Cuyahoga County. Why should the burden be limited to only Cuyahoga taxpayers?
In addition, almost all of these publicly subsidized institutions pay no property taxes, leaving the costs of fire, police, school, roads and many other services funded by property taxes. Home and commercial property owners pay more in higher property taxes. And tax abatements – which essentially go to higher income housing – to new and renewed housing also eats into revenue sources
But why does Cleveland have to pay the entire public cost of the Cleveland Browns playing field? Why do Cuyahoga County taxpayers have to pay essentially the entire cost of the playgrounds of the Cleveland Cavaliers and Cleveland Indians?
Most of the residents can’t even afford to attend these high-priced events.
The local taxpayers can no longer afford the many publicly-dependent institutions that provide entertainment for a much wider – and much wealthier – audience than the people of Cleveland and Cuyahoga County.
This is a problem of the entire northeast Ohio area, its residents and its taxing structure. The financial burden then should be shared more widely.
We hear a lot of talk about regionalism. This could be a most rewarding form of regionalism.
Why do Cuyahoga County residents alone have to pay for the culture tax that provides funds for some of our major (orchestra, museum) cultural institutions and many smaller arts and culture institutions?
The time is coming – really it has passed – when all the institutions this once wealthy city enjoyed and afforded can be supported by a shrinking and far less wealthy population.
We’re running out of the resources to finance what we have. Too institutionally rich; too economically deprived.
Now is the time to let the people of Lake, Summit, Medina, Lorain, Geauga know that they need to share in the burden of the cost of Cleveland and the treasurer of Cleveland and Cuyahoga County that they enjoy. Of course, some of the same type institutions in outlying areas should share in the wider financing method, whatever that becomes.
It’s time to think about a more regional tax approach to service the wealth of institutions in our communities. It ought to start with capturing taxes on a progressive basis from the beginning.
It’s a matter of fairness. The tax burden must be widened to a larger pool. It should also go where the money is.